Amazed And Confused- I Am Alive

Neil Diamond was the Idols Mentor last night. Neil Diamond’s Career is toasted as a major songwriter, internationally acclaimed recording artist, and touring act. As a songwriter Neil Diamond produced hits for himself and other artists since the 1960’s. He has a 120 million lifetime record sales and in 2002 and ranked only third behind Sir Elton John and Barbara Streisand.

This Article is written and owned by: Arnelle Durocher

The top five sang two songs each last night. Would this be a night that Jason Castro shined?

Jason Castro chose to sing “Forever in Blue Jeans and Summer Morn”. I happen to disagree with the Judges critique of his performances. I thought he really did well, not spectacular but I thought he was pretty good and for the first time I actually enjoyed his performances. In my opinion one of Jason’s problems is not his selection of music it is his nervousness that is affecting his performances. As calm as he looks while singing on stage he is a bundle of nerves inside.

David Cook- sang “I am alive and all I really need is you”. No surprises, David Cook never lets us down, he sings, he swings, he rocks and he delivers for our listening pleasure. David Cook reminds me of Ruben Studdard in personality. There is no fuss or muss with David. He just comes out, delivers his song, blows it out of the ballpark, takes his bows and plans for the next song. David is very calm, cool and collective in his persona and he is a brilliant and excellent singer. American Idol has had many rockers in their top 12, but I can honestly say, the only one I have enjoyed listening to in any season is David Cook.

Brooke White- First of all I want to know why Ryan always, always, always seems to give Brooke more stage time with his lame questions. It seems to me that Ryan may have his Seacrest eye on Brooke. However, it is not entirely fair that Ryan sits down with only Brooke each show and gives her time. Brooke of course wants to outdo everyone else, and chose to play two instruments. As usual, and with no surprises, Brooke bombed. I think it is remarkably dense that the judges keep telling her she shone when she stank and tanked. I am going to reiterate, Brooke is a mediocre singer, however she would make a helluva talk show host, and she would because of her personality. I think Brooke needs to consider that her personality is a gift. Her personality shines and I could see myself watching a show she hosts, but as a singer to be honest I would not buy her records. Brooke is not exactly Mariah Carey, whom I will buy her records without hearing the whole album. I do not have to hear Mariah’s whole album, I know it is going to be good and something I will enjoy and worth the money I spend on the album.

David Archuletta- sang ,”Sweet Caroline and America”- David really did an outstanding job on both songs and again young David proves he is not planning to leave anytime soon. This kid is brilliant for his age, he really performs well and is a great singer. David continues not to be swayed or to become big headed over his fame and his popularity. I think that is remarkable for a young man with his enourmous talent. This kid will become huge one day.

Last but not least is American Idol Judges consistent underdog of bah’s and humbugs, Syesha Mercado, who sang, “Hello Again and Thank the Lord for Nighttime”. Neil Diamond praised Syesha’s vocals. Go figure a man that is internationally acclaimed with over 120,000 songs to his work and credit, and who would know if someone sang his song correctly or not. Then the Judges, specifically Simon, runs her down and tells her she is in a bit of trouble. I think that is what Simon is hoping. How can they honestly say that Syesha’s excellent performances are beneath Brook White’s? Between Simon and Ryan they seem to be pushing Brooke along no matter how terrible she sings, and Simon denies Syesha her rightful critiques which is she is a contender for Idol title.

In my opinion out of the top five, David Cook, David Archuletta and Syesha are the ones that have a chance at Idol title. Carly Smithson and Michael Johns should have had a chance at Idol title. The fact that Michael and Carly were eliminated and Brooke is still there is baffling. The fact that Simon may be deaf and praises Brooke over Syesha is laughable. I am sorry there is no way in hell that Brooke outshone or out sung Syesha. Jason Castro did better then Brooke.

If America voted on what they heard then Brooke White will be going home tonight.
Who I think should be going home: Brooke White
Whom will America send home: Jason Castro

The best performances of the night is difficult to choose this week. David C, David A and Syesha all tied for number one in overall performances this week. Not one was better then the other, but all three gave excellent, well done, brilliant, hit it out of the ballpark performances.

This was a night that we continue to see Simon tank in his judgment and critiques; and Ryan moon after Brooke, which is unfair for a judge and a host to continue to do. Randy Jackson and Paula Abdul are trying to give honest critiques, which I for one appreciate. Paula did have a faux pas and lost focus; however, I would think that it would be hard for Paula to refocus when she has three people talking to her at the same time. Paula looked stunning last night. As Paula gets older, she seems to become more beautiful. Even Randy is putting his dawg and bling on with his selection of clothing. Ryan looked liked he was dressed for a funeral, and then there is Papa with his new bag on. What is it with Simon; he can only wear one color at a time. It is nice to see him in a different color, yet he will only wear the one color. Simon needs to live it up, and take risks in his choice of clothes he may come out and surprise us.

For more American Idol news go to Sirlinksalot.net for all your reality needs!

To Donate or for more information for this great cause for humanity go to Idol Gives Back and contribute for the sake of the children

As of last week, American Idol raised over 65 million dollars.

Read My Article and BB9 members comments On The Modern Day Racism and Women Bashing On The BB9 Forum!

© Copyright Truth Is Pagan Media That Bites 2007- 2008